I didnt taking any sides because I didnt know much about both of you. What I know from your post, Pokye request dispute from Paypal and you didnt answer anything to Paypal, if I didnt missed any info since you didnt said anything about your side to Paypal.
And I dont know any of your tnc except u didnt give source code, which I saw from last post that you didnt tell it anywhere from your screenshot.
I also didnt saw Pokye listed at developers or admin listed here : https://rathena.org/board/staff/
But the real thing that im curious is... are you the one that arguing about this debate ?